“Your Website Isn't on Google's First Page.” I Get Those Emails Too.
I get the e-mails promising Google's first page too. Why that sentence says almost nothing on its own, what I'd ask the sender, and how a review differs from a sales pitch.
Not long after the new version of the GE-KO website went live, I received an e-mail that probably every website owner knows. The site looks good, it says. A shame it isn't on Google's first page. The sender can get it there, and offers a free SEO report to start with.
I won't name the sender or share any details. It doesn't matter who it was, and I don't want this post to be a swipe at someone doing their job. What matters to me is something else: I get these messages too, even though I work on website optimisation myself. So practically everyone gets them. And most owners have no way of judging how much truth is in them.
So I'd like to explain why the sentence "your website isn't on Google's first page" tells me almost nothing on its own. And what I would ask before trusting anyone with my site.
First page for what?
Google's first page doesn't exist as a single place. There is a first page for a specific query, in a specific language, in a specific location, on a specific device. Google says so itself: ranking takes into account, among other things, the user's location, language and device, which is why results for the same query differ from place to place.
When someone writes that a site isn't on the first page, my first question is: for which query? For the company name, a site is usually in first place within days. For a generic term like "web design", it competes with companies that have been in the field for years. For a long, specific question asked by someone with a real need, the picture can be different again.
A message that doesn't say which query it's talking about isn't describing my site. It's describing a template the sender has also sent to a few hundred other people.
Which query actually has business value
Even if a site were in first place for some term, that doesn't mean the business gains anything from it. I'd first separate two things: what people type when they are still researching, and what they type when they are already looking for someone to hire.
Someone searching for "what is SEO" probably won't order a service the same day. Someone searching for "website redesign for a sole trader" already has a fairly clear intent. For a small business it often makes more sense to be well visible for a few specific queries like that than to compete for a generic term that brings many visits and few enquiries.
The difference in search intent is my first question in any conversation about visibility. If we don't talk about it, we're talking about numbers, not about the business.
A new site versus a site Google already knows
In my case, the new version of the site had been online for only a short time. Google needs time to visit new pages, index them and start understanding what they're relevant for. It promises no timeline; its documentation even says explicitly that it doesn't guarantee it will crawl, index or serve a page at all, even one that follows all of its recommendations.
So a message that concludes, days after a redesign, that the site "doesn't rank" is premature at best. It doesn't say whether the site is in the index yet, whether the old links were redirected properly, or whether the domain has any history to build on.
In an actual review, that is exactly what I'd look at first: what Google already knows about the domain. How many pages are indexed, which queries already bring impressions, where the site already shows up without any effort. Only from that can you say what is realistic to expect.
Competition isn't a number in a report
Automated reports like to show a "difficulty" score for a keyword. That tells me less than it seems. I'm more interested in who actually holds the top positions for the query that matters to the business.
If it's large platforms, directories and media, the path for a small business is different than if it's local providers with average websites. In the first case I'd look for narrower queries and local context. In the second, a clear, fast site with a concrete presentation of the service may already be enough.
You can't read that from a single number. You have to look.
How I tell a review from a sales message
Having read quite a few messages of this kind, I've made myself a simple test. A real review talks about my site. A sales message talks about Google in general and about everything the sender can guarantee me.
A few signs by which I recognise an automated message almost every time:
- it names no specific query for which the site isn't visible,
- it doesn't say what's actually wrong with the site, only that it "doesn't rank",
- it promises the first page or the first position,
- it offers a "free report" generated by a tool that could be produced for any domain,
- it compliments the site with a sentence that would apply to any site.
Google says something similar in its guidance on choosing an SEO provider. No one can guarantee a number one ranking; be wary of those who claim to, or who claim a special relationship with Google; and treat unsolicited e-mails offering SEO services with the same scepticism as other unsolicited offers. That's not my opinion of the senders; it's the documentation of the company whose first page they're promising.
What I would ask
If I were a site owner without technical knowledge and received a message like this, I'd ask the sender a few questions. Not to catch them out, but because the answers quickly show whether the person has the site open at all.
Which three queries do you think my site should be visible for, and why those? What specifically on the site is preventing it? What would you change in the first month, and how will we know whether it helped? What changes will you make to the site, and will I see and understand them?
A good provider is happy to answer these, because they're the questions they ask themselves. A poor one moves on to the price of the package.
The report a tool produces
The free SEO report offered in such messages is usually the output of a tool that checks a few dozen technical points: missing meta descriptions, image sizes, the number of H1 headings, speed. That data isn't worthless. I use it in reviews myself.
But a list of technical warnings is not a website review. A review starts with the question of what the visitor actually wants to do on the site, and only then gets to the metadata. A technical warning about a missing description can be justified while the site's biggest problem is that nobody understands what the company does. A tool doesn't notice that. A person who opens the site and reads it does.
What an owner can check in fifteen minutes
Before replying to a message like this, I'd take a quarter of an hour and check a few things that need no paid tool.
I'd type the company name into Google and see whether the site appears and what the result looks like: title, description, any subpages. Then I'd type two or three queries I think customers use and look at who is on the first page. Not to compare myself, but to see whom I'm competing with and whether there's room there at all for a company my size.
If I had access to Search Console, I'd look at the performance report: which queries already bring the site impressions and clicks. That is the only data that says where the site already is, not where someone thinks it should be. If I didn't have access, I'd set it up; it's free and takes minutes.
Finally, I'd open the site on my phone and try to do what I want a visitor to do. Call, send an enquiry, find a price. If that doesn't go smoothly, the answer to the message is clear: Google's first page wouldn't help, because the visitor would leave right after clicking. If you also wonder whether AI search engines can read the site, the checklist for that is in How to Check Whether Your Website Is Ready for AI Search.
What a review I take seriously looks like
When I get a review from someone who has really looked at the site, I recognise it because it talks about concrete things on my site and ties every finding to an effect on the visitor or the business. Not by the length of the report, and not by the number of red icons.
A good review says which queries matter for the business and why. It says where the site isn't visible for them and what the likely reason is: content that doesn't answer the question, a technical obstacle, too little trust in the domain, or simply too little time. It says what should be changed, in what order, and how we'll measure whether it helped. And it says what is outside the provider's influence; that's often the most honest page of the report.
A review like that is work, not an attachment to a sales e-mail. That's why nobody sends one to a stranger for free, and why a free report from an unsolicited message is by definition something else.
What the message actually showed me
What the message showed me, above all, is that it hadn't looked at my site. The new version had been online for a short time when it was sent, which is too early for any judgement about visibility, and there was nothing in the message suggesting the sender had checked that at all. No query, no specific fault, no question.
I don't hold it against the people who send these messages. For some of them it's probably the only way to find work. But I'd like to tell site owners something simple: a message that doesn't know your site can't tell you what's wrong with it.
A good provider asks first
If one thing remains from this post, let it be this. A serious conversation about visibility doesn't start with a promise; it starts with questions. What the company sells, to whom, where, whom it competes with, what has changed on the site and what the site is supposed to achieve in the first place.
Only then can anyone say which queries make sense, how long it will take and how we'll measure whether the work helped. All of that is less attractive than a sentence about Google's first page. It's also the only thing I'm willing to promise myself.
